Stupidities -> Homeclick!

Cette page en franšaisCliquez!

Life on Mars debate:

Mars past life: denial with no reason:

Again, news agencies have managed to publish big titles giving an impression that there are no bacterial fossils in the Mars meteorites, when actually there is no reason at all to think so.

Peter R. Buseck of Arizona State University has claimed that the evidence for bacterial fossils in the ALH84001 Martian meteorite are inadequate.

But Peter R. Buseck does not say why. He actually did not study the meteorite at all. He has never even seen the material. He just said that, with an advanced microscope, it could be investigated, and that he plans to investigate.

When it comes to the case for life on other world, just like for the case of studying the UFO phenomenon, oddly, some scientists still simply forget that science is not about issuing conclusions before investigation is done. Peter R. Buseck should have first led his advanced microscopy experiment, and then communicate his findings. He rather chose to alert the media who quickly issued the simplistic and unfounded statement to the general public. Luckily, some media do provide the whole picture and not just the big title, so that interested readers can get the underlying facts rather than the unfair claim.

Since the ALH84001 meteorite was first studied in 1996, 5 years of intense scrutiny by several scientific teams have taken place. The evidence that it contains bacterial fossils has grown in number and relevance to the point that leading teams know that it is only a matter of time before the entire scientific community agrees with their findings. They also know that there will be denials without backing up facts.

See also this page for a summary of ideas about life on Mars, and this page about the magnetite subjected to this controversy, and this page to read that this denial is just a rerun.

Here is the original Associated Press release:

Researcher Says NASA Has Failed To Prove Case for Bacteria Fossils in Martian Meteorite:

By Paul Recer
Associated Press
posted: 09:00 am ET
20 November 2001

WASHINGTON (AP) _ A group of researchers say scientists at the U.S. space agency have failed to prove their contention that a Mars meteorite contains evidence of ancient microbial life on the Red Planet.

A group led by Peter R. Buseck of Arizona State University said that the researchers at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration have inadequate evidence showing that tiny crystalline structures in Mars meteorite ALH84001 were formed by bacteria billions of years ago as the rock was sitting on the Martian surface.

A study with Buseck as the first author appears Tuesday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Buseck said that NASA-supported researchers claimed in February that crystals found in the meteorite are identical to crystals formed on Earth by bacteria. The material, known as magnetite, is formed by some bacteria that live on the bottom of lakes. The magnetic crystals act as a sort of compass to allow the bacteria to orient themselves as they move along the lake bottom.

Buseck said there was inadequate similarity between Earthly magnetite and that found in the Mars meteorite to prove that the material was formed by a living organism.

"We find that there is much more uncertainty than they seem to believe," said Buseck, referring to the NASA researchers.

The Arizona State researcher said there are computer-driven electron microscope techniques that can be used to determine if the NASA researchers are correct. He said he plans to do such a study.

Everett Gibson, a NASA researcher who was among the group that first proposed that ALH840001 contained evidence of life, said that Buseck has not even looked at the Mars meteorite.

"How can he draw this conclusion without seeing the material?" Gibson asked. He said that other researchers have found evidence that supports the NASA group.

In 1996, Gibson and some other NASA-supported researchers announced that they had found evidence in ALH84001 of life - microscopic fossils that could have been bacteria, and carbon chemicals that are linked to life processes.

They suggested that the bacteria lived on the Red Planet billions of years ago, when Mars had water and warmer temperatures, and that microbes left evidence inside the Mars rock.

ALH84001 is thought to have formed on Mars about 4.6 billion years ago and is the oldest of 16 meteorites found on Earth that have been identified chemically as coming from Mars.

Scientists believe that an asteroid smashed into Mars 13 million to 16 million years ago and catapulted into orbit a chunk of Mars that contained ALH84001. The Mars rock wandered in space for millions of years and finally fell to Earth about 13,000 years ago. It was found on the Allen Hills ice field in Antarctica in 1984 and has been intensely studied since.

Gibson said that other scientists have found evidence that supports the findings of his NASA team.

"Our group feels more strongly about our hypothesis now than we did in 1996," he said.

Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict

 Feedback  |  Top  |  Back  |  Forward  |  Map  |  List |  Home
This page was last updated on November 18, 2001.