ACUFO index -> Home 

Cette page en françaisCliquez!

ACUFO:

ACUFO is my comprehensive catalog of cases of encounters between aircraft and UFOs, whether they are "explained" or "unexplained".

The ACUFO catalog is made of case files with a case number, summary, quantitative information (date, location, number of witnesses...), classifications, all sources mentioning the case with their references, a discussion of the case in order to evaluate its causes, and a history of the changes made to the file.

Previous case Next case >

Munich, Germany, on October 30, 1944:

Case number:

ACUFO-1944-10-30-MUNICH-1

Summary:

On his historical ufology website, US ufologist Jan Aldrich, circa 2020, documented a case of October 29, 1944, near Munich, Germany.

Aldrich explained that the report was taken from the August 1994 issue of The Raven, newsletter of the 301st Bomb Group association, that it was only a one-line mention of a "Foo Fighter" or UFO, but of possible interest:

The incident appeared in the report by William A. Schultz, a 419th pilot, of a sosoliray mission flying over the Adriatic, the Alps, then enroute to Munich at about 1:45 a.m. he told, ...

"We had broken out of the high scattered clouds when a strange phenomenon occurred. A light blue colored ball of fire approximately three feet in diameter appeared about 40 feet off of our right wing tip. It actually flew along with us for about 30 seconds with streams of fire trailing down, but it was too large to be a plane. To this day, I don't know what it was."

(They then approached the west side of Munich, completed the mission, with some damages.)

Data:

Temporal data:

Date: October 30, 1944
Time: 01:45 a.m.
Duration: 30 secondes.
First known report date: August 1994
Reporting delay: 5 decades.

Geographical data:

Country: Germany
State/Department: Bavaria
City: Munich (München)

Witnesses data:

Number of alleged witnesses: 1 or more.
Number of known witnesses: 1
Number of named witnesses: 1

Ufology data:

Reporting channel: Veterans bulletin.
Visibility conditions: Night.
UFO observed: Yes.
UFO arrival observed: Yes.
UFO departure observed: Yes.
UFO action: Flies along plane.
Witnesses action:
Photographs: No.
Sketch(s) by witness(es): No.
Sketch(es) approved by witness(es): No.
Witness(es) feelings: Puzzled.
Witnesses interpretation: Unidentified.

Classifications:

Sensors: [X] Visual: 1 or more.
[ ] Airborne radar:
[ ] Directional ground radar:
[ ] Height finder ground radar:
[ ] Photo:
[ ] Film/video:
[ ] EM Effects:
[ ] Failures:
[ ] Damages:
Hynek: NL
Armed / unarmed: Armed, 5 7.62 mm machine guns.
Reliability 1-3: 2
Strangeness 1-3: 1
ACUFO: Possible meteor or ball lightning.

Sources:

[Ref. prt4:] JAN ALDRICH - "PROJECT 1947":

N - 1944.10.30 - 0145 hours, Munich, Germany,

419th Bomb Squadron, B-17 on a "Lone Wolf" mission. A light blue ball of fire paced aircraft for a time. (The Raven, 301st Bomb Group veteran's publication, August 1994.)

[Ref. gvo1:] GODELIEVE VAN OVERMEIRE:

1944, October 30

Germany, Munich

At 1:45 a.m. the pilot of a B17 bomber (419th USAAF squadron) saw a ball-shaped blue light pass by (PROJECT ACUFOE, Catalog 1999, Dominique Weinstein)

[Ref. dwn2:] DOMINIQUE WEINSTEIN:

Case 52

October 29-30, 1944

Munich, Germany

Twelve B-17s (419th Bomber Squadron / 15th Air Force 15th Wing) operating on 15 mn intervals, took off separately on a "Lone wolf" operation to harass the enemy. Their target was in Munich area. At 0145, one of the B-17 pilot, William A. Schultz, flying at 26,000 feet and approaching Innsbruck when suddenly the upper gunner reported that a boogie was heading toward them, looking like an apparent twin engine JU-88. The pilot dropped to alower altitude and maneuvered his plane into thick clouds. When they had broken the the high scattered clouds a strange phenomenon occurred. According to Schultz, "a light blue colored ball of fire, approximately three feet in diameter appeared about 40 feet off our right wing tip. It actually flew along wuith us for about 30 seconds with streams of fire trailing down, but it was too large to be a plane.

Sources: Project 1947, Jan Aldrich/ The Raven, 301 st Bomb group veteran's publication, August 1994 / Strange companies, Keith Chester, 2007

[Ref. nip1:] "THE NICAP WEBSITE":

[1944] Oct. 29, 1944; Munich, Germany

Light blue colored ball of fire approximately three feet in diameter. (Page 85-86 Ref.1)

The reference 1 is described at the end of the document as "Strange Company (2007), Keith Chester".

[Ref. prt4:] JAN ALDRICH - "PROJECT 1947":

October 29, 1944 - Near Munich, Germany

This was taken from the August 1994 issue of The Raven, newsletter of the 301st BG association. An interesting mention of a "Foo Fighter" or UFO. Just a line but of possible interest:

The 15th AAF began night raids, calling the operation "Lone Wolf." The (LW) after the date designates a Lone Wolf mission.

The following account by William A. Schultz, a 419th pilot, describes the use of RADAR on one af the few missions of this type flown by the 15th AAF.

Oct. 29 Mission #365 - Munich West M/Y [Marshaling Yard] (night mission)

Twelve pilots were selected from the 5th Wing (B-17s) to fly the first night mission by the U.S. Army Air Force in the Mediterranean Theatre of Operations. As one of the pilots, my scheduled bomb drop was 2:15 A.M. The crew assembled for briefing and was jeeped to our plane at 10:00 P.M., take off was 10:30. Our twelve plane bombing intervals were approximately 15 minutes. This nuisance raid was significant in that not only was the mission at night, but we were equipped with twelve 500 pound bombs with six instantaneous explosives and six delayed action fuses from 5 to 72 hours. Demoralizing!

In flight, over the Adriatic, the crew test-fired our guns about 10:45 P.M. We saw tracer flashes ahead and signaled with our scope light the proper call letters. As we approached the north shore of the Adriatic enroute to Munich, we could see by the moonlight heavy cloud formation over the Alps. It had to be a cold front coming down from Germany. At 20,000 feet there was a "saddle back" in the frontal mass of clouds and we picked this to go through. We encountered severe down drafts and lost 1000 feet of altitude in seconds, then through the opening, we encountered up drafts that made the plane rise like an elevator another 2000 feet. As we approached Innsbruck, the IP, we were above the clouds at 26,000 feet when we encountered tracer shells coming toward our plane. T/Sgt. Dominick Walicki, crew chief and top turret gunner yelled, "Ju-88 at 10 o'clock!" It looked like a twin engine aircraft. We immediately dove down into the clouds. I told the crew members to hold their fire as we had no flame dampeners on our guns and we did not wish to give our position away to other enemy aircraft that might be in the vicinity.

Note:

Our plane was equipped with a "Mickey Scope" (radar) that could "see" through the clouds. The Mickey navigator informed me when we were over the IP and gave directions to the West Marshaling Yard at approximately 1:45 A.M. We had broken out of the high scattered clouds when a strange phenomenon occurred. A light blue colored ball of fire approximately three feet in diameter appeared about 40 feet off of our right wing tip. It actually flew along with us for about 30 seconds with streams of fire trailing down, but it was too large to be a plane. To this day, I don't know what it was.

(End of part about the "UFO").

As we approached the west side of Munich, we encountered heavy antiaircraft fire and surmised that we were too close to the German Airdrome S.W. of Munich where the Me-262s were being manufactured. Upon encountering heavy flak, we made a sharp turn to the left to avoid the concentration. The navigator said to take a 90 degree course to the target. This of course put us right through the middle of the flak, but the correction was made and I related to Lt. Jess Miller, our bombardier, to keep the bomb bay doors closed until we were about one minute from the target. The flak was intense. We made the drop and immediately dove and banked at 45 degrees to our right, approximately 200 feet. Our tail gunner, Sgt Orvin Larson, relayed to me the track of shell bursts, and taking evasive action, rolling 45 degrees to our left, there would be a cluster of shell fire at the point where we made the turn. That old B-17 was creaking from the strain of doing over 200 MPH during the evasive dives. Over the target, we were hit at the chin turret and that was disabled. The windshield in front of the pilot was cracked. The rudder became like a sieve and my radio operator, Sgt. Stempien, had his oxygen mask hose cut by a piece of shrapnel. Shortly after taking evasive action, the #2 engine was hit and feathered. Sgt. Phil Smith, the right waist gunner, advised that he thought the #2 engine was on fire and this was extinguished and the prop feathered before we lost our hydraulic oil.

[Ref. tai1:] "THINK ABOUT IT" WEBSITE:

Date: Oct. 29, 1944

Location: Munich, Germany

Time:

Summary: Light blue colored ball of fire approximately three feet in diameter.

Source:

Aircraft information:

The US B-17 "Flying Fortress" was a heavy bomber fitted with five 7.62 machine guns for its defense against enemy fighter planes.

B-17 formation.

Discussion:

The plane is said to be a B-17 of the 419th Bomber Squadron of the 15th Wing of the 15th US Army Air Force.

Historical sources confirm that William A. Schultz was a pilot with the rank of 2nd Leutenant in 1944, Captain when he retired, assigned to the 301st Bomb Groupf of 419th Squadron. He was from Minneapolis. He had earned the Air Medalfrom the 15th Air Force in 1944, then the Air Medal Bronze Oak Leaf Cluster, and the Distinguished Flying Cross.

William A. Schultz.

His crew on July 8, 1944 was Schultz, William A, Pilot; Hubscher, Paul, CP; Lathrop, Robert, Y; Weinstein, Russell, B; Malicki, Dominick, Flight Engineer; Stempien, John A, R; Smith, Philip, Gunner; Sgt Larson, Orvin W, Gunner.

Map.

Because it was not specified whether the phenomenon had a trail or not, I cannot tell whether it could heve been a meteor or not.

Because the color was reported as blue, this report is different from all other "good" reports of the so-called "Foo Fighters" reported by pilots in WWII, in which the phenomenon is of red or orange color.

As a consequence, it is one of the rare case in which the explanantion by some electrostatic penomenon such as St-Elmo fire cannot be discarded either. St-Elmo fires were advanced as an explanation for the Foo Fighters in WWII already.

Though, about St-Elmo fire, I want to point out that this kind of explanation is itself quite shaky. For example, there is not even one photograph of the phenomenon. Only illustrations, artists's views exist.

This phenomenon is not stritly defined; but it is generally said that it is a luminous pnemomenon appearing on ship's masts or plane wingtips, and of bluish color. It is generally not "ball-shaped"

I would much rather talk of ball lightning, a better-known phenomenon, whose occurrence is beyond doubt. It is ball-shaped, it is sometimes bluish.

Evaluation:

Possible meteor or ball lightning.

Sources references:

* = Source is available to me.
? = Source I am told about but could not get so far. Help needed.

File history:

Authoring:

Main author: Patrick Gross
Contributors: None
Reviewers: None
Editor: Patrick Gross

Changes history:

Version: Create/changed by: Date: Description:
0.1 Patrick Gross October 31, 2023 Creation, [prt4], [dwn2], [nip1], [prt3], [tai1].
1.0 Patrick Gross October 31, 2023 First published.
1.1 Patrick Gross November 4, 2023 Addition [gvo1].

Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict



 Feedback  |  Top  |  Back  |  Forward  |  Map  |  List |  Home
This page was last updated on November 4, 2023.